PolitiFact Virginia: Warner Fouled On Final Four Claim | Community Idea Stations

Connect:

PolitiFact Virginia: Warner Fouled On Final Four Claim

Speaker: Mark Warner

Statement: Other than University of Virginia’s 2019 basketball team, “We’ve not had a Virginia team even in the Final Four in over a decade. I think George Mason was the last one…”

Date: April 9, 2019

Venue: TV interview

At 64, U.S. Sen. Mark Warner still mixes it up on the basketball court, elbowing under the boards, talking trash, and chiding himself when he misses a shot.

Warner was beaming on April 9, the day after the University of Virginia beat Texas Tech in overtime to win the NCAA men’s basketball championship. “They brought glory to Virginia and they did it in a way the people will remember for a long, long time,” Warner, D-Va., said during an interview with WHSV TV-3 of Harrisonburg.

No college in Virginia had won the men’s tournament before, and Warner said it had been ages since one had even made the semifinals.

“We’ve not had a Virginia team even in the Final Four in over a decade,” he said. “I think George Mason (University) was the last one, in on a kind of wild ride they took.”

We ran Warner’s claim through the Truth-O-Meter.

George Mason did make the Final Four in 2006, to great surprise. None of the players was taller than 6 feet 7, none went on to play in the NBA. Although the Patriots finished the regular seasons with a 22-6 record, their at-large selection to the NCAA tournament was criticized by CBS basketball announcer Billy Packer, who thought them undeserving.

The Patriots beat Michigan State in the first round, then upset defending champion North Carolina after falling behind 16-2. Next, they topped Wichita State, then got to the Final Four by upsetting top-seeded Connecticut in overtime.

The semifinals did not go well. GMU lost to Florida, the eventual champion, 73-58.

Contrary to Warner, however, there was a another state team that made it to the Final Four before UVa this year. And it happened in the last decade.

Warner forgot about Virginia Commonwealth University in 2011.

The Rams were no sure bet to chosen to play in the tournament; they were 23-11 and had finished fourth in their conference standings. Sportscaster Dick Vitale called VCU’s inclusion in the tourney “an injustice, totally unfair...It would be like a beauty contest. Roseanne Barr walking in, versus Scarlett Johansson. No shot. None whatsoever.”

But once play began, VCU went on a tear with their “havoc” defense under coach Shaka Smart. First came double-digit wins against Southern California, Georgetown and Purdue. Next, was a 72-71 overtime win over Florida State. To get to the Final Four, they upset top-seeded Kansas, 71-61.

An estimated 1,000 VCU students spilled out on Broad Street that night in celebration. The team returned to Richmond the next day and was greeted by 5,000 fans. VCU struggled to meet the demand for Final Four t-shirts in the school’s black and gold colors.

Once again, however, the dream ended in the semifinals. VCU lost to Butler, 70-62. Two days later, Connecticut beat Butler for the national championship.

How could Warner forget the Rams? The senator suggests that upsets in the 2011 tourney - including those by VCU - sent his pool predictions crashing. “If your bracket got blown up as bad as mine did in 2011, you’d probably block out all memory of that tournament, too,” he said in an email. “I guess these are the problems you have when you come from a Commonwealth with so many great teams.“

We should note we found another inaccuracy in Warner’s TV interview that also hints college basketball has taken has taken a back seat in the senator’s mind to stuff like U.S. intelligence operations, banking laws and technology.

Warner inflated Virginia Tech’s performance in this year’s tournament. “The Hokies came within one basket of also getting into the Final Four,” he said.

In fact, Tech lost by two points to Duke in the Sweet 16 round. The Hokies would have had to win that game and one more to get to the Final Four.

 

Our ruling

Warner said other than University of Virginia’s 2019 basketball team, “We’ve not had a Virginia team even in the Final Four in over a decade. I think George Mason was the last one…”

We’re calling a foul. VCU made the Final Four in 2011 - less than a decade ago. We rate Warner’s statement False.

 

Sources

U.S. Sen. Mark Warner, Interview with WHSV TV-3 (0:40 and 2:03 marks), April 9, 2019.

The Virginian-Pilot, “Mark Warner, Democrat,” Oct. 12, 2008.

NBA, Historic players list, accessed April 11, 2019.

The Washington Post, “ Mason Madness ,” March 4, 2016.

Virginia Tech, 2011 men’s basketball scores , accessed April 11, 2019.

Richmond Times-Dispatch, “VCU Celebrates and Waits,” March 29. 2011.

ESPN, “ Dick Vitale Goes Off ,” March 13, 2011.

Email from Rachel Cohen, Warner’s communication director, April 15, 2019.